Canada Reads 2014: Why I liked the Final 2.

Canada_Reads_2013-11-26_620x350_2420973387Wab Kinew stated it best when he said that the two main issues facing Canada are reconciliation and the oil sands, and I wholeheartedly agree. Wab Kinew did say most things best in this competition. Though Samantha Bee said things pretty darn well herself. So, it’s no big surprise for me that The Orenda won this year’s Canada Reads with the theme of “the book that will change Canada.” From a story perspective, while I haven’t read The Orenda yet, I know Boyden’s work and the writing is always excellent. I’m absolutely sure this book deserved to win.

A lot of people seem to have been upset that Annabel was taken out of the running, but I was okay with it given the theme of the competition. It was a funny thing to listen to this morning as I was pretty hard on Rawi Hage in a previous post about his occasional rudeness about doing the publicity parts of his job as an author, and then he goes and sends bagels to everyone on the panel. But, I started championing Cockroach, though I don’t think I’ll ever read it (too dark for me), because I had a really large reaction when panelists like Lewis said that the extremity of isolation expressed as the immigrant experience in Canada in this book were not realistic. Being a first generation Canadian, I got to see my parents’ experience as well as that of their immigrant friends, and I can tell you it was a youth spent watching immigrants come full of hope to this country and then fall through the cracks of the Canadian system. The isolation for some was unbearable, and so the idea that are educated people out there who would think “Oh, that can’t be in Canada, our immigrant experience could never be that bad,” just set my blood boiling a bit. The fact that Cockroach brought to light the isolation of both the mentally ill and the immigrant in this country, and the state of mind of immigrants coming in from war-torn nations, and that Samantha Bee did such an excellent job of expressing herself about these issues, made me quite happy that this book made it to the final 2.

But all the issues brought up in the year’s Canada Reads were good ones. If you’re interested in more, the Literary Press Group has given some lovely ideas with their Canada Reads Indie suggestions.

What about you? Were you happy with the way this competition went?

About writereads

A Canadian book club podcast that will change the world of literature forever.
This entry was posted in Opinions, Tania. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Canada Reads 2014: Why I liked the Final 2.

  1. lauratfrey says:

    This is my first time watching and I am so pleasantly surprised by the quality of the debate. Particularly Wab Kinew, but everyone was so articulate and smart and sincere.

    I haven’t watched in the past because I wasn’t aware of it till a couple years ago, and because I was (and still am to some degree) dubious about the premise – it seems a little artificial to debate which book is “better” when the message is really “they’re all great.” But that’s a problem with any award I suppose!

    This is must-watch for me from now one. I’m really curious about what happened two years ago as I’ve seen that referenced a few times.

    Tania, you have to read The Orenda! Maybe I’ll write my review now to inspire you even more 🙂

  2. writereads says:

    Please do write your review so I’ll be inspired to read it! 🙂

    The Canada Reads are a bit hit and miss. This was a great year and I was really happy with it. There were only two debaters that I didn’t think were all that great, but they still weren’t bad. And it’s a very worthwhile competition to have as it gets us all riled up about books, which I always enjoy.

    2012 was not a good year, it was a year that made some people stop listening. It was the first year of non-fiction, so I wasn’t as into it, but it was also a year when the debaters were super personal in their attacks and the whole thing was just a mess in my opinion.

  3. Naomi says:

    I was so happy with the way it all turned out! I watched the whole thing for the first time, and was also impressed with the quality of debate from Wab, Samantha, and Stephen. I thought they said some great things about both our past and our present. And I was happy withe the winner (my best book of 2013).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s